Master Modals: Fixing 100 Common Mistakes with Modal Verbs

Introduction: Common Mistakes with Modal Verbs

Modal verbs – can, could, may, might, must, shall, should, will, would – are deceptively simple. Their power to express necessity, possibility, permission, and ability is unmatched, yet their specific rules are frequently misunderstood. Mastering them is crucial for anyone aiming for precision in professional or academic English. This article directly addresses the most pervasive common mistakes with modal verbs, providing a comprehensive list of errors, clear corrections, and strategic advice to eliminate these errors from your writing and speech, especially under exam conditions.

Important Tips for Students & Exam Candidates:

The “To” Trap: Remember, modal verbs are immediately followed by the base form (infinitive without ‘to’) of the main verb. The mistake “He must to go” is a critical error. Correct: “He must go.”
Tense Limitations: Modals themselves do not change form for person (e.g., he can, not he cans). To express different times, you often need to switch the modal (e.g., can for present ability, could for past ability/general possibility).
Double Modals are Invalid: In standard English, you cannot use two modals together. “I might will go” is incorrect. Use alternatives: “I might be going” or “I will possibly go.”
Distinguish Certainty Levels: Understand the hierarchy of certainty: must (strong certainty) > should (expectation) > may/might/could (possibility). Using must for a guess is a common mistake.
“Shall” vs. “Will”: In modern English, especially for exams, use shall primarily for first-person questions (“Shall I open the window?”) offering or suggesting. For simple future, will is universally accepted.

Here are 100 full examples of common mistakes with modal verbs and their corrections.

Incorrect: She can to swim very well.
Correct: She can swim very well.
Incorrect: He musts finish his homework.
Correct: He must finish his homework.
Incorrect: They will to arrive tomorrow.
Correct: They will arrive tomorrow.
Incorrect: You should to drink more water.
Correct: You should drink more water.
Incorrect: It may raining this evening.
Correct: It may rain this evening.
Incorrect: We could to order pizza.
Correct: We could order pizza.
Incorrect: I might to go to the party.
Correct: I might go to the party.
Incorrect: You must not to smoke here.
Correct: You must not smoke here.
Incorrect: She will can help you later.
Correct: She will be able to help you later.
Incorrect: I would like a tea, please? (as a direct question)
Correct: Could I have a tea, please?
Incorrect: He may comes late to the meeting.
Correct: He may come late to the meeting.
Incorrect: They shall to overcome.
Correct: They shall overcome.
Incorrect: You ought respect your elders.
Correct: You ought to respect your elders.
Incorrect: I need not to worry about it.
Correct: I need not worry about it.
Incorrect: She dare not to confront him.
Correct: She dare not confront him.
Incorrect: This must be the manager, isn’t it? (tag question)
Correct: This must be the manager, isn’t he/she?
Incorrect: You should must apologize immediately.
Correct: You must apologize immediately.
Incorrect: I can able to complete the task.
Correct: I am able to complete the task. / I can complete the task.
Incorrect: It can be true! It’s impossible.
Correct: It can’t be true!
Incorrect: Would you mind to close the window?
Correct: Would you mind closing the window?
Incorrect: I used to could run fast.
Correct: I used to be able to run fast.
Incorrect: May you pass the salt? (asking for ability)
Correct: Can you pass the salt?
Incorrect: We must finish this yesterday.
Correct: We should have finished this yesterday.
Incorrect: He told me he will come. (reported speech, past tense)
Correct: He told me he would come.
Incorrect: You can be right about that.
Correct: You could be right about that.
Incorrect: Must I go now? (asking for permission, sounds severe)
Correct: May I go now?
Incorrect: I would if I can.
Correct: I would if I could.
Incorrect: It must have been expensive, mustn’t it?
Correct: It must have been expensive, wasn’t it?
Incorrect: You had better to revise your notes.
Correct: You had better revise your notes.
Incorrect: I will might see you tomorrow.
Correct: I might see you tomorrow.
Incorrect: Shall you be attending the conference?
Correct: Will you be attending the conference?
Incorrect: The report can have been finished by now.
Correct: The report could have been finished by now.
Incorrect: She must be tired, I’m not sure.
Correct: She might be tired, I’m not sure.
Incorrect: You must have called me first! (criticism)
Correct: You should have called me first!
Incorrect: Could you please to explain again?
Correct: Could you please explain again?
Incorrect: It’s may possible that he forgot.
Correct: It may be possible that he forgot.
Incorrect: He can have arrived by now. (past possibility)
Correct: He could have arrived by now.
Incorrect: We would had left earlier if we knew.
Correct: We would have left earlier if we had known.
Incorrect: You must be new here, am I right?
Correct: You must be new here, aren’t you?
Incorrect: I would like that you come early.
Correct: I would like you to come early.
Incorrect: Can you tell me where is the bank?
Correct: Can you tell me where the bank is?
Incorrect: She can be at home, her car is outside. (weak deduction)
Correct: She might be at home, her car is outside.
Incorrect: Will we start the meeting? (making a suggestion)
Correct: Shall we start the meeting?
Incorrect: You would enjoy this book, I promise.
Correct: You will enjoy this book, I promise.
Incorrect: I may not agree, but I can not be certain.
Correct: I may not agree, but I am not certain.
Incorrect: Children should must listen to their parents.
Correct: Children must listen to their parents.
Incorrect: He needs must complete the form.
Correct: He must complete the form.
Incorrect: If it will rain, the match will be cancelled.
Correct: If it rains, the match will be cancelled.
Incorrect: I wish I can help you.
Correct: I wish I could help you.
Incorrect: You mustn’t have parked there; it’s illegal.
Correct: You can’t have parked there; it’s illegal. / You shouldn’t have parked there.
Incorrect: She might to consider the offer.
Correct: She might consider the offer.
Incorrect: You would better see a doctor.
Correct: You had better see a doctor.
Incorrect: He said he can speak Japanese.
Correct: He said he could speak Japanese.
Incorrect: This can be the best solution.
Correct: This could be the best solution.
Incorrect: You must feel cold, shall I close the window?
Correct: You must be feeling cold, shall I close the window?
Incorrect: I used to would visit my grandmother.
Correct: I used to visit my grandmother.
Incorrect: Need I to fill out this form?
Correct: Need I fill out this form? / Do I need to fill out this form?
Incorrect: You shall not pass! (archaic/formal for prohibition)
Correct: You cannot pass. / You are not allowed to pass.
Incorrect: Might I borrow your pen? (overly formal in casual settings)
Correct: Can I borrow your pen?
Incorrect: The keys must be in the drawer, but they’re not.
Correct: The keys should be in the drawer, but they’re not.
Incorrect: You can have told me earlier!
Correct: You could have told me earlier!
Incorrect: Will I help you with those bags? (offering help)
Correct: Shall I help you with those bags?
Inorrect: He must be the director, mustn’t he?
Correct: He must be the director, isn’t he?
Incorrect: She would always helped her friends.
Correct: She would always help her friends.
Incorrect: You mustn’t eat so much candy; it’s bad for you. (strong advice)
Correct: You shouldn’t eat so much candy; it’s bad for you.
Incorrect: I can’t find my phone; it can be lost.
Correct: I can’t find my phone; it could be lost.
Incorrect: You will better hurry up.
Correct: You had better hurry up.
Incorrect: He may has left already.
Correct: He may have left already.
Incorrect: They must to follow the instructions.
Correct: They must follow the instructions.
Incorrect: Would you like that I call back later?
Correct: Would you like me to call back later?
Incorrect: If you would have asked, I would have helped.
Correct: If you had asked, I would have helped.
Incorrect: She can be very rude sometimes. (for typical behavior)
Correct: She can be very rude sometimes. (This is actually correct: ‘can’ for occasional behavior).
Incorrect: He should be more careful, but he wasn’t.
Correct: He should have been more careful.
Incorrect: You must be joking, are you?
Correct: You must be joking, aren’t you?
Incorrect: I will must ask my boss for permission.
Correct: I must ask my boss for permission. / I will have to ask my boss.
Incorrect: It might could happen.
Correct: It might happen. / It could happen.
Incorrect: You shall regret this decision.
Correct: You will regret this decision.
Incorrect: Can you be able to finish on time?
Correct: Will you be able to finish on time?
Incorrect: You don’t must leave yet.
Correct: You must not leave yet. / You don’t have to leave yet.
Incorrect: She may not to know the answer.
Correct: She may not know the answer.
Incorrect: I would rather to stay home.
Correct: I would rather stay home.
Incorrect: He must have been a great athlete, didn’t he?
Correct: He must have been a great athlete, wasn’t he?
Incorrect: They can’t have won the game; they were terrible.
Correct: They can’t have won the game; they were terrible. (This is correct for disbelief about the past).
Incorrect: You should to try the new restaurant.
Correct: You should try the new restaurant.
Incorrect: I may would consider it.
Correct: I might consider it. / I would consider it.
Incorrect: Need I to wear a tie?
Correct: Need I wear a tie? / Do I need to wear a tie?
Incorrect: You must feel better after resting.
Correct: You must be feeling better after resting.
Incorrect: Will you please to be quiet?
Correct: Will you please be quiet?
Incorrect: If I knew, I would tell you, can’t I?
Correct: If I knew, I would tell you, wouldn’t I?
Incorrect: The project must complete by Friday.
Correct: The project must be completed by Friday.
Incorrect: He said he may join us.
Correct: He said he might join us.
Incorrect: You would like to see this, I think.
Correct: You will like to see this, I think.
Incorrect: Can you be at the station at 8? (for arrangement)
Correct: Will you be at the station at 8?
Incorrect: She mustn’t have seen the email yet.
Correct: She can’t have seen the email yet. / She might not have seen the email yet.
Incorrect: I should be there, but my car broke down.
Correct: I would be there, but my car broke down.
Incorrect: You might as well to give up now.
Correct: You might as well give up now.
Incorrect: He can be sleeping; let’s not disturb him.
Correct: He could be sleeping; let’s not disturb him.
Incorrect: You must to understand the rules.
Correct: You must understand the rules.
Incorrect: Would that I can turn back time.
Correct: Would that I could turn back time.
100.Incorrect: They may to decide later.
Correct: They may decide later.

FAQs: Common Mistakes with Modal Verbs

Q1: What is the single most common mistake people make with modal verbs?
A: The most frequent error is adding “to” after a modal verb. Remember the rule: Modal + Base Verb. Incorrect: “She can to swim.” Correct: “She can swim.”

Q2: How do I choose between ‘may’ and ‘might’ for possibility?
A: Both indicate possibility, but ‘might’ often suggests a slightly lower probability or a more hypothetical situation. In practical terms, they are often interchangeable, but ‘may’ is slightly more formal. For past possibility, always use “might have” or “may have.”

Q3: Is it wrong to use ‘will’ in conditional (‘if’) clauses?
A: In the standard first conditional (real possibility), use the present simple in the ‘if’ clause and ‘will’ in the main clause: “If it rains, I will stay home.” Using ‘will’ in the ‘if’ clause (e.g., “If it will rain”) is a common mistake, except in rare cases involving willingness (e.g., “If you will help me, we can finish faster”).

Conclusion: Common Mistakes with Modal Verbs

Eliminating common mistakes with modal verbs is a transformative step towards grammatical accuracy and confident communication. By internalizing the rules against double modals, remembering the base verb form, and precisely selecting modals for the intended meaning of certainty, permission, or ability, you can significantly enhance the clarity of your English. Consistent practice using these corrections will ensure that these subtle but critical errors no longer hinder your performance in exams or professional settings.

Disclaimer: Common Mistakes with Modal Verbs
This article provides guidance for standard, formal English usage. Please note that regional dialects and informal spoken English may sometimes use modal verbs differently. For authoritative examination standards, always refer to the specific guidelines of your testing body.

Also Read: Mastering Reported Speech: Your Complete Guide on How to Change Direct Speech to Indirect Speech

How to Use Too and Enough: The Complete Guide with 100+ Examples